Navajo Nation water disputes placed on US Supreme Court Docket

Map of the Navajo Nation
Spread the love

Jurist.orgOpens in a new tab. reports that two water cases involving the Navajo Nation have been placed on the U.S. Supreme Court docket.

The first is Arizona v. Navajo NationOpens in a new tab..  SCOTUS blog identifies the issues:

  1. Whether the opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, allowing the Navajo Nation to proceed with a claim to enjoin the secretary of the U.S. Department of the Interior to develop a plan to meet the Navajo Nation’s water needs and manage the mainstream of the Colorado River in the Lower Basin (LBCR) so as not to interfere with that plan, infringes upon the Supreme Court’s retained and exclusive jurisdiction over the allocation of water from the LBCR mainstream in Arizona v. CaliforniaOpens in a new tab.; and
  2. Whether the Navajo Nation can state a cognizable claim for breach of trust consistent with the Supreme Court’s holding in United States v. Jicarilla Apache NationOpens in a new tab. based solely on unquantified implied rights to water under the doctrine of Winters v. United StatesOpens in a new tab..

The second case is titled Department of the Interior v. Navajo NationOpens in a new tab., where the issue is described by SCOTUS Blog as “Whether the federal government owes the Navajo Nation an affirmative, judicially enforceable fiduciary duty to assess and address the Navajo Nation’s need for water from particular sources, in the absence of any substantive source of law that expressly establishes such a duty.”

The Winters doctrine generally means that when the federal government created a reservation for the Tribes, the act of establishing a reservation created reserved rights for the Tribes to have a sufficient water supply while living on the reservation.

The Navajo Nation is over 17 million acres and is the largest tribal reservation in the United States.  It covers portions of northeastern Arizona, northwestern New Mexico, and southeastern Utah.

Image:  Public domain locator map of the Navajo NationOpens in a new tab..

Deborah

Since 1995, Deborah has owned and operated LegalTech LLC with a focus on water rights. Before moving to Arizona in 1986, she worked as a quality control analyst for Honeywell and in commercial real estate, both in Texas. She learned about Arizona's water rights from the late and great attorney Michael Brophy of Ryley, Carlock & Applewhite. Her side interests are writing (and reading), Wordpress programming and much more.

2 thoughts on “Navajo Nation water disputes placed on US Supreme Court Docket

  1. Ok, I’m reading this again because I don’t understand #1. If the Court of Appeals stepped on SCOTUS’s toes I’m sure it will be rectified. As for #2, I think the Federal Government does owe the Navajo Nation affirmation in this area. I really don’t know enough about this stuff and it is part of the reason I keep coming back to this site. To learn more.
  2. Seventeen million acres is a lot of land! And finding water sources on the Navajo Nation seems exceedingly difficult.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Skip to content