Colorado puts agricultural conservation on hold

Colorado River source in Colorado
Spread the love
  • Colorado will not include farmers and ranchers in its 2027 water conservation program.
  • State officials want guarantees that conserved water will remain under Upper Basin control.
  • Federal officials say any agreement on how saved water affects reservoir operations must involve all seven Colorado River Basin states.
  • A smaller conservation program involving nonagricultural water users remains possible.
  • The federal government has provided $100 million for conservation programs in four Upper Basin states.

Saturday, November 21, 2026 — Colorado farmers and ranchers will not participate in the state’s planned 2027 Colorado River conservation program after federal officials declined to guarantee how the saved water would be managed.

The Colorado Water Conservation BoardOpens in a new tab. discussed the decision during its November 18 meeting, reversing course from a conditional approval granted in September.

The program would pay water users to temporarily reduce their water use, allowing more water to remain in the Colorado River system.

But Colorado officials want assurances that those savings will benefit the Upper Basin states rather than potentially increase the amount of water released downstream.

Without those guarantees, state water managers say there is not enough time for farmers and ranchers to plan their participation for the 2027 growing season.

According to Heather Sackett, reporting for Aspen JournalismOpens in a new tab. on November 19, board members may consider a smaller conservation program involving nonagricultural water users at their January meeting.

ā€œWe are very late in the year at this point,ā€ Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief for the Colorado Water Conservation Board, told board members, according to Sackett’s reporting. ā€œIt would be really challenging, I think, for a lot of agricultural water users to consider enrolling at this point without this certainty.ā€

The Disagreement Over Saved Water.

The dispute centers on a concept called operational neutrality.

Under Colorado’s preferred arrangement, water saved through the conservation programOpens in a new tab. would be credited to the Upper Basin states and held in reservoir storage without affecting decisions about how much water must be released downstream.

This matters because Lake Powell’s annual releases are influenced by the amount of water stored in the reservoir.

If conservation increases Lake Powell’s water level, that additional storage could affect release decisions and potentially allow more water to flow downstream to Arizona, California and Nevada.

Colorado officials want to prevent their conservation efforts from producing that result.

The state argues that water users should receive credit for their sacrifices and that conserved water should remain available for purposes agreed upon by the Upper Basin states.

According to Sackett’s November 19 report, Becky Mitchell, Colorado’s representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission, explained the concern during the board meeting.

She reported that Colorado wants to assure participating water users that they are not simply saving water so others can increase their consumption.

Federal Officials Say More Negotiations Are Needed.

The federal government has not rejected the idea of crediting conserved water to the Upper Basin states. However, it has declined to provide the operational guarantees Colorado requested.

In a November 10 letter to the Upper Colorado River CommissionOpens in a new tab., Andrea Travnicek, assistant secretary for water and science at the U.S. Department of the Interior, explained that decisions about how conserved water affects reservoir operations require broader negotiations.

ā€œThere is currently no water within the Colorado River Basin that is considered operationally neutral,ā€ the letter stated.

The letter also explained that reservoir operations would continue to depend on actual water elevations until additional agreements are reached.

Federal officials said any arrangement involving the storage, release, or special treatment of conserved water would require discussions among all seven Colorado River Basin states.

The Bureau of Reclamation remains willing to work with the Upper Basin states on measuring conserved water, verifying contributions and establishing a system for providing credit.

For Colorado, however, those discussions have not produced the assurances needed to move forward with agricultural participation in 2027.

What Happens to the $100 Million Conservation Program?

The federal government has provided $100 million to support voluntary water conservation in Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming.

The money is being distributed through the Upper Colorado River Commission.

According to the Colorado Water Conservation Board’s November 18 staff memorandum, Colorado has access to 51.75 percent of the funding under an implementation agreement executed by the Bureau of Reclamation on November 10.

The funds remain available through 2031, and officials anticipate that the money could support approximately two or three years of conservation projects.

The program would compensate participants who voluntarily reduce their water use, with contributions directed toward Lake Powell or designated upstream reservoirs, including Flaming Gorge, Blue Mesa and Navajo.

Colorado’s September approvalOpens in a new tab. established a process for evaluating proposed conservation projects. It also required an agreement ensuring that contributed water would receive operationally neutral credit.

That condition has not been satisfied.

According to Sackett’s reporting, Utah and Wyoming are continuing with conservation programs that include agricultural water users.

Colorado officials, meanwhile, may pursue a more limited program involving municipal or other nonagricultural participants.

Sackett reported that at least one Front Range water provider has expressed interest in participating by reducing its use of Colorado River water.

Farmers Face Difficult Choices

Agriculture accounts for much of the Colorado River Basin’s water consumption, making farms and ranches an important part of conservation discussions.

However, asking agricultural producers to temporarily stop irrigating land can affect farm income and rural communities.

Some Western Slope water managers have warned against moving too quickly without clear agreements governing the conserved water.

In her November 19 articleOpens in a new tab., Sackett reported that water managers and irrigation district representatives urged the state to avoid launching an agricultural program without protections for Upper Basin contributions.

Colorado has considered similar programs before.

From 2019 through 2021, nine workgroups examined a voluntary conservation approach that would compensate water users for temporarily reducing consumption. The Colorado Water Conservation Board ultimately declined to implement that program.

The state also participated in a federally funded conservation pilot program during 2023 and 2024.

According to Sackett, the four Upper Basin states conserved approximately 101,000 acre-feet of water through that program at a cost of $45 million.

Colorado contributed approximately 24,300 acre-feet.

An acre-foot is enough water to cover one acre of land to a depth of one foot.

Recent Rainfall Shows the Challenge.

The amount of water saved through voluntary conservation can be small compared with changes caused by weather.

During the November 18 meeting, Ostdiek pointed to recent rainfall and flooding that substantially increased water flowing into Lake Powell.

According to Sackett’s reporting, Ostdiek said Lake Powell had gained approximately 1.3 million acre-feet during the preceding month and a half.

She compared that increase with previous conservation results, noting that it represented roughly 26 years of savings at the earlier pilot program’s pace.

The Colorado Water Conservation Board’s November 18 memorandum also described the effects of recent storms.

Heavy precipitation and flooding during September and October improved storage conditions at several reservoirs, including Lake Powell, Lake Mead, Navajo Reservoir and Vallecito Reservoir.

However, the memorandum reported that northern Colorado’s headwater basins remained significantly drier than normal and that Blue Mesa Reservoir storage remained at a record low.

These differing conditions illustrate the challenges facing Colorado River water managers as they develop conservation programs during prolonged drought and unpredictable precipitation.

Colorado Keeps Its Options Open; Increases Litigation Fund.

Although agricultural participation is off the table for 2027, Colorado has not abandoned the broader conservation effort.

State officials will continue discussions with the Bureau of Reclamation and other Upper Basin states over how conserved water should be measured, credited, stored and released.

The Colorado Water Conservation Board is expected to revisit the possibility of a smaller program at its January meeting.

The board also approved increasing Colorado’s water litigation fund from $6 million to $10 million at its November 18 meeting, according to Sackett’s reporting. Of that amount, $4 million was allocated to Colorado River Basin matters.

For now, Colorado’s agricultural conservation program remains on hold while state and federal officials work through the unresolved question of who receives credit for water saved in the Upper Colorado River Basin.

Deborah

Since 1995, Deborah has owned and operated LegalTech LLC with a focus on water rights. Before moving to Arizona in 1986, she worked as a quality control analyst for Honeywell and in commercial real estate, both in Texas. She learned about Arizona's water rights from the late and great attorney Michael Brophy of Ryley, Carlock & Applewhite. Her side interests are writing (and reading), Wordpress programming and much more.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Recent Posts

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
Skip to content