Lawsuit challenges water use at Project Jupiter data center

Project Jupiter in New Mexico
Spread the love
  • A new lawsuit challenges groundwater use for Project Jupiter, a massive data center under construction in southern New Mexico.
  • The complaint says nearly 196 million gallons of water have been used for construction.
  • Environmental advocates say the state approved a change in water use without required public notice and hearings.
  • The dispute centers on an emergency permit issued to replace a failing irrigation well.
  • The lawsuit seeks to stop further construction-related water use until New Mexico complies with state law.

Friday, November 20, 2026 — A dispute over groundwater in southern New Mexico has reached the courts, raising questions about how water once used for farming can supply a massive data center.

On November 19, 2026, the Center for Biological DiversityOpens in a new tab. filed a lawsuit against the New Mexico Office of the State Engineer and State Engineer Elizabeth Anderson, challenging the state’s authorization of groundwater for construction of Project Jupiter in Doña Ana CountyOpens in a new tab..

The environmental organization claims state officials violated New Mexico’s water laws and constitution by allowing water historically used to irrigate a sod farm to be used for industrial construction without the required public review.

The lawsuit, filed in the First Judicial District Court in Santa Fe County, seeks to halt further use of the disputed water for Project Jupiter until the state satisfies its legal obligations.

Nearly 196 Million Gallons Used for Construction.

According to the complaintOpens in a new tab., construction of Project Jupiter began in September 2025.

The project is described as a hyperscale data center, a large facility designed to handle enormous amounts of computer processing and data storage.

Water for construction has been supplied through groundwater rights held by Santa Teresa Capital, LLC.

The complaint cites state water records showing that, between September 2025 and October 2026, approximately 636 million gallons were pumped under the company’s water right.

Of that amount, about 195.5 million gallons were reported as having been used specifically for Project Jupiter construction.

The distinction matters because the water right also serves an existing commercial sod farm.

The complaint says the company’s water right allows up to 2,400 acre-feet annually for several purposes, including irrigation, commercial, industrial, municipal and recreational uses.

How a Failed Irrigation Well Became Part of the Dispute.

The controversy began with an application Santa Teresa Capital submitted on October 21, 2025.

The company requested emergency authorization to replace a groundwater well that had experienced mechanical problems.

According to the application quoted in the lawsuit, the existing well had suffered a substantial decline in production because of damage to its screen and casing. Other wells had also failed.

Santa Teresa Capital argued that delays in replacing the well could hurt production at the commercial sod farm and delay construction of a major industrial project.

Two days later, on October 23, 2025, the Office of the State Engineer granted emergency authorization.  The approval stated:  “An emergency situation exists in which delays caused by publication and hearing may result in economic loss.”

The authorization also stated that preliminary investigations indicated the replacement well would not cause greater depletion of the Rio Grande or greater interference with neighboring wells than the original well had historically caused.

The Center for Biological Diversity disputes whether the circumstances qualified as an emergency under state law.

Its complaint argues that the authorization went beyond replacing a failing well because it also permitted water to be used for construction of Project Jupiter.

Beneficial Use: Why the Environmental Group Says the Approval Was Illegal.

At the center of the lawsuit is a basic principle of New Mexico water law known as beneficial use.

Under the state constitution, beneficial use determines the basis, amount, and limits of a water right.

The environmental organization argues that water rights cannot simply be held for possible future uses without regard to how the water has actually been used.

According to the complaint, the disputed water right originated from a much larger water authorization issued in 1981 for anticipated development in the Santa Teresa area.

Over time, portions of that original right were separated. The water right now held by Santa Teresa Capital was formally created in 2005.

The complaint says its established use was primarily irrigating a commercial sod farm, even though the written authorization continued to allow several other types of water use across a much larger area.

The environmental group contends that the state should have considered that history before permitting construction-related water use.

The complaint also challenges the state’s use of an emergency provision that allows certain replacement wells to be drilled before the usual public notice and hearing process.

According to the lawsuit, that exception does not authorize a new use of the water.

Public Participation Is Another Major Issue.

New Mexico law provides procedures for reviewing proposed changes in groundwater use.

Those procedures include public notice, an opportunity to object and, when required, a hearing.

State officials must also consider whether a proposed change could interfere with existing water rights, water conservation or the public welfare.

The Center for Biological Diversity alleges that those protections were bypassed when the state approved the emergency well replacement.

Sarah BaerOpens in a new tab., an attorney with the organization, said, “This lawsuit takes aim at the Office of the State Engineer’s failure to enforce our water laws and protect New Mexico’s most scarce and precious resource.”  Baer also argued that the decision denied residents an opportunity to participate before irrigation water was diverted to construction.

The complaint further alleges that state officials exceeded their legal authority and violated constitutional protections involving due process and separation of government powers.

Rio Grande Water Obligations Add to the Dispute.

The lawsuit also raises concerns about New Mexico’s obligations involving the Rio Grande.

According to the complaint, the state’s groundwater settlement obligations include reducing pumping in Doña Ana County by 18,200 acre-feet over ten years.

The environmental organization argues that allowing additional pumping under the disputed water right could interfere with those requirements.

The complaint also questions whether the state’s approval adequately considered possible impacts on nearby wildlife and habitats.

It cites a New Mexico wildlife assessment identifying at least 17 animal species of conservation concern within approximately 2,000 meters of the Project Jupiter construction site.

These environmental and interstate water concerns form part of the organization’s argument that the state should have conducted a more thorough review before allowing the disputed use.

What Happens to Project Jupiter’s Water Supply?

The lawsuit asks the court to require the Office of the State Engineer to bring the disputed water right into compliance with New Mexico law.

It also seeks an order preventing Santa Teresa Capital from supplying additional water under that right for Project Jupiter construction or other new uses until the legal requirements are satisfied.

According to figures cited in the complaint, the Office of the State Engineer estimates that Project Jupiter construction will require approximately 750 acre-feet of water, or about 244 million gallons.

With approximately 600 acre-feet already reported as used for construction through October 2026, the estimate leaves roughly 150 acre-feet, or nearly 49 million gallons, for remaining construction needs.

The complaint also cites state estimates of additional water needed to fill the data center’s cooling and fuel-cell systems, along with ongoing water needs to refill those systems.

A separate administrative proceeding concerning the requested well-location change was already pending when the lawsuit was filed.

The newly filed court action challenges broader questions involving the water right itself, the emergency authorization and the public review process.

The case is Center for Biological Diversity v. Office of the State Engineer and State Engineer Elizabeth Anderson, Case No. D-101-CV-2026-03211Opens in a new tab..

Image of proposed Project Jupiter via the Doña Ana County websiteOpens in a new tab..

 

Deborah

Since 1995, Deborah has owned and operated LegalTech LLC with a focus on water rights. Before moving to Arizona in 1986, she worked as a quality control analyst for Honeywell and in commercial real estate, both in Texas. She learned about Arizona's water rights from the late and great attorney Michael Brophy of Ryley, Carlock & Applewhite. Her side interests are writing (and reading), Wordpress programming and much more.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

Recent Posts

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x
Skip to content